To Top
PlayNetwork Independent US gambling guides · state by state You're on PlayPennsylvania

Jump To Your State

Federal Judge Dismisses Oklahoma Tribal Gaming Compact Challenge

A federal judge dismissed four Oklahoma tribes’ challenge to gaming compacts negotiated by Gov. Kevin Stitt, finding they lacked standing.
Oklahoma State Capitol: Oklahoma City
PlayPennsylvania News Team Avatar
2 mins read
Share Share
Copy link Share on X Share on Facebook Share on Reddit Share via Email

U.S. District Judge Timothy Kelly dismissed a six-year challenge to Oklahoma tribal gaming compacts for lack of standing, The Journal Record reported Nov. 17. The judge found that the four plaintiff tribes had not shown a redressable injury caused by federal approval of the agreements.

Photo: Daniel Mayer / CC BY-SA 3.0 / Wikimedia Commons, cropped

The Cherokee, Chickasaw, Choctaw and Citizen Potawatomi nations challenged compacts Gov. Kevin Stitt signed with the Comanche Nation and the Otoe-Missouria Tribe of Indians in April 2020.

Judge rejects claims of competitive and economic injury

The court docket records the complaint’s filing on Aug. 7, 2020, in the U.S. District Court for the District of Columbia. The case is Cherokee Nation v. U.S. Department of the Interior.

According to The Journal Record, the tribes argued that the compacts were invalid under the Indian Gaming Regulatory Act. Then-Interior Secretary David Bernhardt allowed the agreements to take effect by taking no action on them.

Kelly rejected theories of competitor standing, equal footing standing and economic harm, the outlet reported.

“Plaintiffs’ economic injury is contingent on an independent action — a change in Oklahoma law — that might (or might not) ever happen,” Kelly wrote, according to The Journal Record.

The compacts allow sports betting and house-banked card and table games, which remain illegal under Oklahoma law.

Additional casinos depended on land being taken into trust

The agreements established new exclusivity fee rates and required quarterly reports to the Oklahoma Office of Management and Enterprise Services. They also promised the governor’s support for taking land into trust for up to three new casinos for each tribe.

Kelly found that those six potential casinos were not impending because they depended on the land-in-trust process, The Journal Record reported.

Oklahoma Attorney General Gentner Drummond supported the plaintiff tribes in a friend-of-the-court brief. Citing the Oklahoma Supreme Court ruling known as Treat 1, Drummond argued that Stitt lacked “actual authority to bind the state” because the compacts were not “legally entered into by both parties,” according to The Journal Record.

21+. Must be physically located in Pennsylvania to play. Gambling problem? Call 1-800-GAMBLER.

—

Source: As reported by The Journal Record.

This article was created with the assistance of AI and is monitored by our editorial team.

AI Disclosure
This content was created, reviewed, and approved by PlayPennsylvania News Team. We use AI to help draft and refine text, but every review, news piece, and update goes through our editorial team before publishing. See our Editor Guidelines for more.
About the Author
VIEW ALL POSTS

The PlayPennsylvania News Team provides everything you need to know about online casinos, retail casinos throughout the state, online and retail sports betting, lottery, and all other legal gambling in Pennsylvania. The content writing process for the PlayPennsylvania News Team includes using an AI application, but the content is edited and fact-checked by real humans. No piece of content is published before human eyes take a fine-tooth comb to ensure its accuracy, reliability, and trustworthiness.

VIEW ALL POSTS