Barstool Sports Advisors NFL Week 5 Picks: Poor Week For Portnoy Who Keeps Doubting Cowboys

Written By Staff on October 8, 2021 - Last Updated on October 15, 2021
Barstool Advisors Week 5 picks

For the second-straight week, only Dan “Big Cat” Katz had a winning record of the trio of Barstool Sports Advisors. Dave Portnoy finished with the worst record, going 2-6-1. Big Cat’s “mortal lock” turned out to be the only winner, too.

Here are the Barstool Advisors Week 5 picks. Also, take a look ahead at updated NFL Week 6 lines at PA sports betting apps.

New York Jets vs. Atlanta Falcons

Dave Portnoy

The pick: Jets +3, Under 46

“That unders Tommy just gave me scream it’s a great pick. I will take the Jets.”


The pick: Falcons -3

“I love London. I love fish and chips and I love the Falcons in this game.”

Big Cat

The pick: Over 46

“I’m going against Tommy’s stat because his accent was bad.”

Final score: Falcons 27, Jets 20

Green Bay Packers vs. Cincinnati Bengals


The pick: Bengals +3, Under 51

“Home dog +3. Aaron is playing good football but I’m going to take the home dog. It seems like a lot of people are going to be on the Packers. I don’t like doing under balls, but I’m going to.”


The pick: Bengals +3

“I think the Bengals are going to be able to run the ball down Green Bay’s throat. They are going to keep Rodgers on the sidelines. Burrow has played well and they are giving him time. He covers the number.”

Big Cat

The pick: Packers -3, Bengals team total over 23.5

Final score: Packers 25, Bengals 22

Cleveland Browns vs. Los Angeles Chargers


The pick: Browns -1.5, Under 47

“The Browns defense is playing lights-out. I think they are a dark horse Super Bowl team. I’m not sold on the Chargers yet. I don’t think I’ve ever done this on the history of the show, I’m going under again.


The pick: Chargers -1.5

“Best game on the card. Chargers are going to win the Super Bowl, bet them at 33-1. Herbert is going to win the MVP. Chargers are the best team in the NFL. Browns are the second-best team in the NFL.”

Big Cat

The pick: Chargers -1.5

“I do think the Chargers are a good team. This is a coin-flip game.”

Final score: Chargers 47, Browns 42

New York Giants vs. Dallas Cowboys


The pick: Giants +7

“I’m not sold on the Cowboys. I don’t know why, they look great.”


The pick: Giants +7

“I think it’s a big number. Maybe Joe Judge can put a fire under everyone asses. Giants are a 6-7 win team. This could be one of them. Dallas is the best team in their division but that’s not saying a lot. I think Giants win the game.”

Big Cat

The pick: Giants +7, Over 52

“I’m back in on Danny Dimes. The Cowboys have the best offense in the NFL right now.”

Final score: Cowboys 44, Giants 20

Buffalo Bills vs. Kansas City Chiefs


The pick:Bills +3

“I think this game matters to the Chiefs. I think the Bills are the best team in the NFL. I’ll put 100k on them to win the Super Bowl. I will let you know if I put a 100k on them 8-1. I think the Bills are Super Bowl or bust this year.”


The pick: no pick

Big Cat

The pick: Bills +3

“I’m worried about how easy this feels because the Bills are the team that lost year. They are hungry the dog.”

Final score: Bills 38, Chiefs 20

Barstool Week 5 “mortal locks”


The pick: Giants +7

“I’ve been a week off on my mortal locks.”

Final score: Cowboys 44, Giants 20


The pick: 49ers +5

“F— Tyler O’Day…”

Final score: Cardinals 17, 49ers 10

Big Cat

The pick: Titans -4

“Give me the Titans. They are going to dog walk Urban Meyer. “

Final score: Titans 37, Jaguars 19

Barstool Advisors 2021 NFL picks overall record

Barstool Advisors Week 5 record

  • Portnoy: 2-5-1
  • Stu Feiner: 2-2-1
  • Big Cat: 4-2-1

Barstool Advisors season record

(Sunday picks only included in overall record) 

  • Portnoy: 12-18-1 (Mortals 0-5)
  • Stu Feiner: 12-12-1 (Mortals 1-4)
  • Big Cat: 15-21-1 (Mortals 2-3)

Bet with Barstool promos

Barstool Sportsbook PA has a number of “bet with Barstool” promos.”

Big Cat’s Can’t Lose Parlay:Vikings to win; Patriots to win; Titans to win; Over 44.5 points in Giants vs. Cowboys; Over 44.5 points in Bills vs. Chiefs. Boosted from +275 to +400. Cashed

Big Cat’s Can’t Lose Parlay Record NFL 2021: 3-2

Compare NFL Week 6 lines

Lead image Barstool Sports YouTube

Staff Avatar
Written by

View all posts by Staff
Privacy Policy